In recent weeks, the luxury automotive industry has been caught in a whirlwind of speculation regarding price adjustments, with BMW at the center of this debateThe company's strategic direction appears to be oscillating as the automotive market in China remains fierce and competitiveOn September 23, a wave of rumors surged through social media, suggesting that BMW was preparing to re-enter the "price war" by dropping prices on several models in the Chinese market.

The context behind these rumors is criticalIn August, BMW's sales reportedly plummeted by nearly half compared to the previous yearThis drastic decline provoked a sense of urgency among industry analysts and consumers alike, leading many to speculate that BMW was feeling the pressure to remain competitive against rivals, especially amidst the rise of electric vehicles (EVs) and aggressive pricing strategies employed by other luxury brands.

However, the following day, representatives from BMW China clarified the situation, denying any changes to the suggested retail prices

Advertisements

They attributed fluctuations in the final retail prices to the volatile market environment, indicating that authorized dealers have the autonomy to adjust prices based on local demandThis statement highlighted the complexities of pricing strategies in the face of shifting market dynamics.

Despite the official denial, reactions from consumers and industry insiders ranged from disbelief to concernOne user pointed out the irony of BMW's struggles to maintain sales in light of its recent price cuts designed to stimulate demandOthers expressed trepidation about the effects of a prolonged price war, fearing that it may devalue luxury brands and erode consumer perception of quality.

This is not the first time BMW has faced challenges in the Chinese marketWith the influx of electric vehicles and the competitive landscape becoming even more crowded, luxury car manufacturers have been forced to adapt

Advertisements

In prior years, BMW experimented with a strategy of "price for volume," where it set lower prices to increase salesIn June, the company was again in the headlines with significant price cuts across its model range, raising questions about the sustainability of such pricing tactics.

Yet, by July, reports emerged that BMW would retreat from the price war, asserting a new focus on maintaining value rather than sacrificing margins for volumeThe company signaled its intention to prioritize business quality over sheer numbers, a strategic shift that included gradual price increases on several modelsThis pivot was seen as an acknowledgment that aggressive discounting did not deliver the anticipated spike in sales volume.

The sales figures tell a story of their ownIn the second quarter of 2024, BMW’s global sales reached 618,700 units, reflecting a slight year-on-year decline of 1.3%. Notably, sales in China dropped from 198,200 units to 188,700 units, equating to a concerning decline of 4.8%. BMW's prior forecasts of a stable market in the third quarter proved overly optimistic, as August results further revealed a steep drop in sales, marking it the second-lowest monthly performance for the brand in China.

As whispers of a reaffirmed price war filled the air, the China Automotive Dealers Association released a report on September 23 that scrutinized the sweeping changes affecting the auto market, including the relentless pricing pressure

Advertisements

Many BMW dealers interviewed echoed sentiments of uncertainty regarding pricing, revealing a reluctance to speak openly about the ongoing adjustments out of fear of jeopardizing their relationships with the manufacturer.

Besides pricing struggles, BMW's reputation has been further complicated by a recent recall announcementOn September 10, BMW revised its financial forecasts for the 2024 fiscal year, indicating that technical issues related to its integrated braking systems would affect over 1.5 million vehiclesThe consequences of this recall not only include potential drops in annual delivery volumes but also the burden of extra warranty costs in the third quarter.

In the first half of 2024, BMW's performance was mixedThe company delivered 1.213 million cars, marginally down by 0.1% from last yearWhile the Chinese market remains BMW's largest single market globally, sales fell by 4.3%, totaling just 376,400 new vehicles sold in the first half

• Bank-Resold Funds Ignite New Price War
• Record Online Sales During Holiday Shopping Season
• Rising Bankruptcy Rates in the U.S.
• BMW Reenters the Price War
• Acceleration of Machine Tool Industry Chain Evolution

The pressures from consumer spending habits and incessant price competition have made selling conditions particularly challenging.

Interestingly, while BMW struggled in China, its performance in European and American markets offset some lossesBMW's deliveries in Europe and the U.Sboth saw slight increases, showcasing a resilient demand for luxury vehicles outside of ChinaThe report indicated that in the first half of 2024, BMW delivered 461,000 cars in Europe, and 230,100 units in the United States, both reflecting year-on-year growth.

Dissecting the performance of BMW’s various brands reveals deeper insights into its overall strategyThe core of BMW Group's achievements remained centered on the BMW brand itself, which reported 1.096 million deliveries in the first half of the year, up by 2.3% compared to the previous yearIn contrast, sales of the MINI and Rolls-Royce brands fell significantly, down 18.8% and 11.4%, respectively

Electric models, particularly, played a vital role in driving growth for BMW, with up to 179,600 units delivered, recording an impressive growth rate of 34.1%.

However, the transition to electric vehicles comes with its challengesDespite the increased sales figures for electric models, BMW's pre-tax profit fell by over 1.3 billion euros for the reported periodThe company's revenue stood at 73.558 billion euros, reflecting little change from the previous year, but its pre-tax profit declined by 14.2% from 9.351 billion euros to 8.023 billion euros.

This drop in profitability, coupled with declining volumes from the MINI and Rolls-Royce brands, has stirred concerns within the companyBMW commented that the decline in MINI sales is primarily due to the transition of its entire product lineup to a new MINI series, which has posed inventory issues that complicated receivables for the first half of the year.

The group also faced liquidity issues, as evidenced by the drop in free cash flow from 3.141 billion euros last year to 2.289 billion euros, largely driven by significant investments in electric vehicles, new models, and infrastructure